Most business owners I work with will tell you their people are what makes their business.
Then a great candidate applies for a role. They wait three weeks to hear anything. The job ad doesn’t really explain what the role involves. They meet four different people who each ask completely different questions. And after all that, they get a two-line email saying they were unsuccessful.
Nobody set out to treat that person badly. But every one of those steps sent a message about what it’s like to work there.
I recently read a thoughtful piece by behavioural scientist Torben Emmerling, The Trust Equation, about how his firm rebuilt its hiring process around trust. His central point has stayed with me: trust between a business and its people doesn’t start on day one. It starts, or quietly erodes, during hiring.
Candidates are interviewing you too
While you’re assessing a candidate, they’re assessing you. How quickly you respond, how clearly you explain the role, how decisions get made and how people are spoken to all tell them what working for you will be like.
The best senior and specialist people usually aren’t desperate to move. They’re comfortable where they are, and they’re looking for reasons to trust a new employer, or reasons not to. And in a region like the Waikato, where so many people in the same industries know each other, candidates talk.
Where trust usually breaks down
When I look at hiring processes that have gone wrong, the same problems come up again and again.
- Nobody owns the process. Several people are involved, but no one is clear on who is running it, who has a say, and who makes the final call. Decisions stall, and candidates are left waiting.
- The role is vague. A generic job description, a wish list of requirements, and criteria that shift halfway through. I wrote about this in Why “Taking a Brief” is the shortcut to a mis-hire.
- Every interview is different. One candidate gets a relaxed chat, the next gets a grilling. When nobody asks the same questions, comparing people comes down to gut feel, and gut feel is where bias creeps in.
- Silence. Weeks without an update, and then a generic rejection after three rounds of interviews. This is the one candidates remember longest.
What a trustworthy process looks like
You don’t need a big HR team to fix this. You need a bit of structure, agreed before the job ad goes out.
- Agree who’s involved and who decides. Name the people on the hiring panel, what each of them is assessing, and who makes the final call.
- Define the role properly. What does success look like at six and twelve months? What’s essential, and what’s a nice-to-have? Our job description template is a good place to start.
- Ask every candidate the same core questions. Then have each interviewer score their answers on their own, before you compare notes. That way the decision comes from the evidence, not the loudest or most senior voice in the room. Here are some good questions to start with.
- Give candidates a timeline, and keep to it. Tell them how many stages there are and when they’ll hear from you. If things slip, say so. A short update is always better than silence.
- Close the loop properly. Everyone who applies deserves an answer. Anyone who reaches the final stage deserves a phone call and honest feedback.
Why it’s worth the effort
The person you hire walks in on day one with the expectations your process set. If it was clear, fair and honest, that’s what they’ll expect from you, and that’s what they’ll give back.
The people you don’t hire leave with a story too. A respectful process turns a “no” into someone who still speaks well of your business, applies again when the timing is right, or recommends a friend.
And a structured process simply leads to better decisions. That matters, because the cost of a bad hire is almost always far higher than the time it takes to get the process right.
How we approach it
At RecruitNet, keeping people informed at every stage isn’t an extra. It’s one of the things candidates mention most when they tell us about their experience with us. We take the time to understand what each person is looking for, we keep them updated, and we give honest feedback, whether or not they get the role.
We do that because we see the person behind the CV. It’s also because the way a hiring process feels is a reflection of our clients, and we want every candidate to walk away thinking well of them.
Final thought
Saying people are your greatest asset is easy. Your hiring process is where you prove it.
If you’d like a second opinion on how your hiring process comes across to candidates, or help with a role you’re about to recruit for, I’m always happy to talk it through. You can get in touch with me here.



